Site icon Center Field

Breaking Down the Film from Marist’s Blowout Loss to Butler

Marist’s narrow win over Morehead State a couple of weeks ago raised a lot of red flags about the current state of the team. While they looked like a well-oiled machine earlier this year, the team that beat Drake 27-22 on the road earlier felt like a distant memory.

Their home game against Butler on Saturday served as a reminder of the gap between this Marist team and the top teams in the Pioneer Football League as their PFL hopes expired with a week remaining in the season.

The Red Foxes didn’t find the endzone once and the defense simply wore out against the run first approach of Kevin Lynch’s Bulldogs, translating to a 28-0 blowout in Butler’s favor.

What specifically translated to such a lopsided final score, and how can head coach Mike Willis and his staff approach it differently to put their final game of the season in the win column?

Play 1

The Bulldogs took the lead with this split zone carry in the early second quarter.

Even with several defenders getting their hands on sophomore running back Michael Dellumo (No. 24), the dominant push of the Bulldogs’ line made it easy work for him to barrel into the endzone.

But the success started on the white board.

By motioning sophomore wide receiver Max Supe (No. 17) across the formation, they force the defender responsible for him in coverage — sophomore defensive back Chase Hatton (No. 21) — to over pursue and commit to defending outside the box. 

It’s one thing to get “a hat on a hat,” it’s another thing for every lineman to win their matchup in dominant fashion. The Bulldogs did both.

With the Red Foxes simply getting outpushed inside and the lack of the extra defender, the Bulldogs got on the board first.

Play 2

Later on in the second quarter, the Red Foxes had the opportunity to tie the score deep in opposing territory. Two incomplete passes followed by a six yard rush by graduate student quarterback Sonny Mannino created a fourth-and-four opportunity.

Going for it on fourth here makes sense. Tying it up before the half could really change the momentum, but it’s the poor pressure plan against the blitz that hurt them.

Given the “do-or-die” nature of a fourth down situation, there has to be a plethora of options for the quarterback.

The Bulldogs lined up with five defenders showing rush, yet Mannino showed no urgency to get the ball out. This led to a knifing senior defensive lineman Jayden Norris (No. 8) getting in his face.

Mannino forces a pass downfield as a result of this and gets intercepted. Considering that the defense was showing pressure up the middle, the lack of a middle field check down option is confusing.

Redshirt freshman wide receiver Jayden Taylor (No. 14) runs through the midfield area after his switch release, but he doesn’t settle there. Instead, he continues upfield and runs into other defender’s coverage. 

It’s unclear whether or not Taylor is given freedom to settle in the midst of his route by the coaching staff, but the lack of flexibility built into such an aggressive fourth down call was what led to the turnover.

Play 3 

The struggles went beyond the passing game. While the run game has been a lot stronger in the latter half of the season, they were not successful on the ground in this game. They averaged just two yards on their 26 rushing attempts.

On inside zone runs, like this fourth and one playcall, the offensive line is coached not to go to the second level until they get a vertical push on the playside defensive lineman.

Senior defensive end Ashton Nawrocki (No.15) and senior defensive lineman Luke Green (No. 44) hold up well on the backside, forcing senior running back Lincoln Cardillo (No. 4) to run into a T-E stunt on the playside. Junior defensive lineman Dantu Gardner Jr. (No. 9) loops outside and senior linebacker Jackson Stratton (No. 5) knifes inside over him. 

Redshirt freshman right tackle Sal LoGrasso (No. 75) passes Stratton on because he works inside of him then goes up to the second level. Redshirt freshman guard Hudson Dalton (No. 56) was not on the same page, staying engaged with the looping defender that he engages with at the start of the play.

Stratton stuffs the run before Cardillo can get the yard and the Red Foxes turn the ball over on downs.

Play 4

On this third and long the Red Foxes are down big and Mannino takes an, understandably, aggressive approach. The issue here, however, is his eyes.

The passing concept is called “bench.” It operates similarly to a “smash” concept. 

This concept is supposed to stretch the flat defender, sophomore cornerback Tristan Johnson (No. 6), with the out route, which was being run by graduate student wide receiver Reed Shumpert (No. 15), keeping Johnson honest underneath. If Johnson over played Shumpert’s out route he’d leave junior wide receiver Zach Garmont (No. 5) wide open on the corner route and vice versa.

The key for Johnson is reading the QB’s eyes. Mannino doesn’t make that hard, staring down Garmont for a hair too long and leading Johnson straight to where he needs to be.

The Red Foxes head into Davidson after their worst performance of the year. Being 1-3 in their last four games, they have to change the momentum if they want to end the season with a win.

The defense can play at a very high level, their quarterback has game changing playmaking ability, and the run game can control a matchup.

When firing on all cylinders, they’ve proven they’re a winning football team. Time will tell if they return to form against 4-7 Davidson.

Edited by Max Rosen

Graphic and photo by Jaylen Rizzo

For more coverage of Marist athletics, follow @cfmarist on Instagram, X, TikTok and Bluesky, and sign up to receive daily alerts here.

Exit mobile version